Caedes

Request for Comment

Discussion Board -> Request for Comment -> does this seem constructive?

does this seem constructive?

::third_eye
03/29/07 10:42 PM GMT
"This is an extreme close up, almost pornograghic, sorry for my brutal frankness. Shall not add this 1 2 my faves."

this message was left at the image of... a bird! sue me, I was trying to present a multi-colored, highly detailed image. nevermind the fact that I got lowballed...again.

Exhibit A
0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery

Comments

Post a Comment  -  Subscribe to this discussion
&KEIFER
03/29/07 10:54 PM GMT
gee .. it sounds as though he adds that comment to ALL images that aren't in his favs .. he must have quite a collection

or .. perhaps he's got a soft spot for you ..
0∈ [?]
*---===>>>>>(¯`·._(¯`·._.: :o) <---- OBLIGATORY SMILEY :._.·´¯)_.·´¯)<<<<<===---*
::J_272004
03/30/07 1:05 AM GMT
ROFLMAO... "Pornographic"???????? a closeup of a birds head??
oh boy... that guy has a twisted mind.. the bird isn't even naked.. its got feathers.. geez... lol.. *shakes head.. wonders what some peoples brains are made of....
0∈ [?]
MY GALLERY ........... "Live one day at a time and make it a masterpiece"
&philcUK
03/30/07 2:46 AM GMT
Parrot Porn?
0∈ [?]
A smart bomb is only as clever as the idiot that tells it what to do
::third_eye
03/30/07 3:03 AM GMT
this dope then PM's me to tell me that a) even though i requested he not comment on my work, he will continue to do so, and b) finds the image in question..revolting. go figure.

now if a parrot is revolting...one can only imagine what he calls pleasing...
0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery
::LynEve
03/30/07 4:55 AM GMT
Being of an innocent and quite and retiring nature I have often wondered what 'pornographic' actually meant - now I know it refers to parrots - well knock me down with a feather !

Cover my eyes and clear my mind.

0∈ [?]
The question is not what you look at, but what you see ~ Marcel Proust
::J_272004
03/30/07 8:37 AM GMT
Lucky I didnt post the pic of the bird I used to have.. he had no feathers..

Rob you can get him for harrassment if he keeps writing junk like that on your images..

Wonders if he's blind in one eye and can't see outta the other..

0∈ [?]
MY GALLERY ........... "Live one day at a time and make it a masterpiece"
.viking_boy
03/31/07 12:45 AM GMT
Well, Rob, I'm with you. No clue what in tarnations he's talking about, however I did notice he's from Bristol, England. Or so he says in his profile. Perhaps there is a cultural differnce that has a different connotation than what you and I see. I remember having a friend tell his girlfriend (in Scotland) something that was quite innocent to you and me but quite vulgar to her.
0∈ [?]
All comments are appreciated. Constructive criticism is greatly appreciated.
::J_272004
03/31/07 1:22 AM GMT
Believe me being from England is NOT a cultural difference.. this guy has a screw loose..
0∈ [?]
MY GALLERY ........... "Live one day at a time and make it a masterpiece"
::mimi
03/31/07 6:17 AM GMT
parrot porn..ROFLAMO @Phil!!

maybe the guy doesn't understand that 'we' call birds of that type "Polly" & was offended. Just a thought on my part. No excuse for public rudeness though.

excellent detail on that image Rob....BTW! ;=)
0∈ [?]
~mimi~
.animaniactoo
03/31/07 11:01 AM GMT
I messaged Rob last nite and asked if I was talking to the Bird Pornographer and if he did extensive research before going into that field or if it was just a "flash" of inspiration. 8•P

On a serious note, I don't think it's constructive, but I do think some people live and think in a world the majority of us will never reach... heck, we might not even drive by the exit for it, and you just gotta go "okayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy" and keep on walking.
0∈ [?]
One man sees things and says "why?" - but I dream things that never were and I say "why not?"
+Samatar
03/31/07 11:29 AM GMT
I think people sometimes use "pornographic" in a metaphorical way to describe something that is over the top (ie in a painting using a very bright and varied palette they might describe the colors as "almost pornographic"). I don't know how that would apply to this photo though and in any case the commenter probably should have explained it a bit better as it is too easy to interpret the comment as insulting (or just weird...)
0∈ [?]
-Everyone is entitled to my opinion- rescope.com.au
&KEIFER
03/31/07 11:47 AM GMT
I understood the use of the word 'pornographic' to be so explicitly close so as to allow no room for modesty

(*bows*)

he is welcome to that view .. the 'rub' was the dismissive nature in which he said it would not make it into his fav's

who cares what doesn't make it into his fav's ..
0∈ [?]
*---===>>>>>(¯`·._(¯`·._.: :o) <---- OBLIGATORY SMILEY :._.·´¯)_.·´¯)<<<<<===---*
+Samatar
03/31/07 11:55 AM GMT
Uh... yeah... that's what I meant to say... :-P
0∈ [?]
-Everyone is entitled to my opinion- rescope.com.au
.animaniactoo
03/31/07 12:05 AM GMT
well that and to refuse to honor Rob's common courtesy request not to comment on any more of his images
0∈ [?]
One man sees things and says "why?" - but I dream things that never were and I say "why not?"
::J_272004
03/31/07 12:20 AM GMT
I'm beginning to think a new section should be created on this site.. Exclusive members only "I-hate-everyones-work-except-mine" or "My-work-only-cos-everyone-elses-suck" or "Big-ego's-only"
0∈ [?]
MY GALLERY ........... "Live one day at a time and make it a masterpiece"
::third_eye
03/31/07 12:28 AM GMT
where do i sign? :P
0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery
::J_272004
03/31/07 12:46 AM GMT
Lol.. now now Rob be a good boy =PP.. lol
0∈ [?]
MY GALLERY ........... "Live one day at a time and make it a masterpiece"
::third_eye
03/31/07 1:02 PM GMT
nuh uh...not coded in my DNA
0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery
&philcUK
03/31/07 2:14 PM GMT
yes - pornography could be used in a different sense - but when it then gets coupled with 'revolting' later on - that makes it meaning a lot clearer and not in a good way.
0∈ [?]
A smart bomb is only as clever as the idiot that tells it what to do
::Hottrockin
03/31/07 6:15 PM GMT
Ya know....

If ya tilt your head a little right and squint your left eye a wee bit....OMG Rob, you sick puppy you!! 8~P

I'm with you bub, I ain't gettin' it and I've compared it with all...uh, of my stuff in my vault shall we say and have came up empty handed. Well, not empty handed but...oh nevermind. 8~O
0∈ [?]
::third_eye
03/31/07 8:50 PM GMT
lmao @ Randy... hope you washed your hands before typing that
0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery
::phasmid
03/31/07 10:40 PM GMT
Well, Rob, you can be glad you did not post a pic of BOOBY BIRD !!! If you had posted two of them think of the repercussions :)PJ
0∈ [?]
"If it makes you cry, it goes in the show." Annie Leibovitz (photographer 1949 - )
.Blumie
03/31/07 10:51 PM GMT
Pornographic????? I must have missed something. But saying, this is a culture difference, can not be the reason, cause I noticed, that people in Europe react most of the time cooler than Americans. I remember the dirty smile of some guys in Texas, when they noticed, where I am from ... I did put this image into my favs and not because of the porno feeling. For sure not!
0∈ [?]
I would be happy, seeing you in my galerie. Today I've posted Greek in front row.
::HauntingMorgana
04/01/07 2:50 AM GMT
Now I've heard everything.

Btw- awesome photo of the parrot!

Michael.
0∈ [?]
Haunting made me do it damnit.
.artytoit
04/01/07 12:27 AM GMT
I'm gonna send the guy some porn links and see if he can spot the difference!
0∈ [?]
::third_eye
04/01/07 6:31 PM GMT
as funny as that is (very) no need to perpetuate the immaturity and childishness. as it is,this dope is still bugging me.

0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery
.ffxfireman
04/01/07 10:27 PM GMT
Maybe recognizing that the picture was pornographic is part of a 12 step program he is going through.
0∈ [?]
Best wide-angle lens? Two steps backward. Look for the 'ah-ha'. Ernst Haas,
::third_eye
04/02/07 12:44 AM GMT
perhaps, but the steps are supposed to go forward...
0∈ [?]
Hi,my name is Rob..ok, so I'm not the greatest at replies and comments. Sorry. For anyone needing to contact me, my email is back up in my profile. >> my cluttered mess of a gallery
.EmilyH
04/24/07 3:36 AM GMT
I would say it's very non-constructive and definitely weird, if not harassing. Perhaps he doesn't know what pornographic actually means.

Or perhaps...yes, perhaps your commenter IS a bird and found it tantalizing. ;p
0∈ [?]
Imagination is more important than knowledge. -- Albert Einstein
::phasmid
04/24/07 3:41 AM GMT
Whooo Whooo what a whoot, emily!!! There's one I hadn't really thought of. :)PJ
0∈ [?]
"If it makes you cry, it goes in the show." Annie Leibovitz (photographer 1949 - )
::DigiCamMan
05/28/07 11:07 PM GMT
Well I never....you could at least put a hat on it. Whata pervert! You should have you camera confiscated and you should never be allowed near children or birds. But it is a rather nice photo and does have tons of detail...just too bad you are a perv. I'm yankin yer chain bro...it is a great shot.

Big Juan
0∈ [?]
I would rather live my life as if there is a God and die to find out there isn't, than live my life as if there isn't and die to find out there is. Albert Camus ........ My Gallery

Leave a comment (registration required):

Subject: