Caedes

Request for Comment

Discussion Board -> Request for Comment -> Is it THAT bad?

Is it THAT bad?

::WENPEDER
03/27/08 6:14 PM GMT
Hi, all. Just checked in to find my recent upload, "The Door" has achieved (is that the right word?) a c-index of 39. Tell me - - is it THAT bad???? Thanks. Wen
http://www.caedes.net/Zephir.cgi?lib=Caedes::Infopage&image=WENPEDER-1205901201.jpg
0∈ [?]

Comments

Post a Comment  -  Subscribe to this discussion
::CanoeGuru
03/27/08 7:41 PM GMT
LINK

:)
0∈ [?]
"What I am is what I am, are you what you are or what?"
&purmusic
03/29/08 4:11 AM GMT
Hope I haven't dissuaded you Wendy, from posting to this thread again in the future. :oP

/\ Inside joke people ... kind of, sort of.
0∈ [?]
"Think what a better world it would be if we all, the whole world, had cookies and milk about three o'clock every afternoon and then lay down on our blankets for a nap." - Robert Fulghum
::LynEve
03/29/08 1:38 PM GMT
is it THAT bad????

NO!!!
0∈ [?]
The question is not what you look at, but what you see ~ Marcel Proust
::WENPEDER
03/29/08 7:06 PM GMT
Hi.... Thanks for posting the LINK and thanks for responding. Les, a great BIG THANK YOU for your e-mail! I have responded to you directly via e-mail but your suggestions were VERY helpful! So, no, you haven't dissuaded me in the least! Again, any and all comments and suggestions are welcome! Wen
0∈ [?]
&purmusic
03/29/08 9:21 PM GMT
Whew!!

Wasn't sure if I had overstepped some boundaries ... wouldn't want to end up lying in some doorway. :oP

You're welcome. :o)
0∈ [?]
"Think what a better world it would be if we all, the whole world, had cookies and milk about three o'clock every afternoon and then lay down on our blankets for a nap." - Robert Fulghum
.artytoit
03/30/08 12:44 AM GMT
39 is an achievement for me! I have 18 images below that, but I don't take any notice of the c-index now. I rely on views, downloads and comments to gauge how popular an image is.
Even then I don't do as well as most :(
0∈ [?]
Arty to IT's Gallery Prints now available at Deviantart under artytoit
::WENPEDER
03/30/08 2:44 AM GMT
Hi, Paul (.artytoit)...after perusing your gallery, I must concur that, from my point of view, your ratings significantly UNDERvalue your images. Keep up the good work! Wen
0∈ [?]
.artytoit
03/30/08 9:40 PM GMT
Thanks Wendy, after some meaningful conversations with Les (purmusic) I think a lot of it may be down to the difference between TFT monitors and CRT monitors. Check out my version of 'Living Dead' and Les's rework and let either of us know what you think?
0∈ [?]
Arty to IT's Gallery Prints now available at Deviantart under artytoit
::WENPEDER
03/30/08 11:33 PM GMT
Well I just took a look at the two versions of "Living Dead" and find the c-index rating of 18 on your original ridiculously low, Paul. I do think that the original version is enhanced by bringup up the brightness, as Les did, but I think your photomanipulation in this piece is quite impressive. I only wish I wouldn't have been eating a sandwich when I checked it out. <G> Nice work. Wen
0∈ [?]
.houstonaxl
04/06/08 12:13 AM GMT
Wendy, I see it is down to a C of 38 but I like it! Images such as this make me wish I had a 3d Render Program. Keep up the good work!
0∈ [?]
My Gallery | "The color of the object illuminated partakes of the color of that which illuminates it." - Leonardo da Vinci|
::HauntingMorgana
04/19/08 12:08 AM GMT
Pay no mind to the C-Index.

I looked at this image and it is, well, very good.

Great job on it!

Michael.

0∈ [?]
How do I get back to Toon Land?
::rob2001
04/19/08 8:33 PM GMT
I remember this picture, I had found it pretty good actually. However, this is not a "mainstream" image. These kind of images do not score well on the c-index in my opinion.
Rob
0∈ [?]
=Samatar
04/20/08 10:18 AM GMT
I think if someone posted this as a photograph, rather than a CG image, some people might consider it a snapshot (eg, someone just took a photo of their own front door). As a painting though, it would be viewed in a different context (IMPO). So maybe you could take it as a compliment that the people who voted mistook it for a photo? But maybe some people would disagree that a photo of this subject would be a snapshot. Just saying what my impression was.
0∈ [?]
-Everyone is entitled to my opinion- rescope.com.au
::WENPEDER
04/20/08 3:30 PM GMT
Hi, all. Thanks for all your feedback. There's always room for improvement, of that I am sure. I just continue to find the low relative scoring on computer generated images noteworthy and am not sure what to make of it. I AM glad to know that some of my favorite artists here didn't think "The Door" was THAT bad though. <G> Wen
0∈ [?]
.oksyl
06/28/08 1:14 AM GMT
Wendy - WARNING! No sugarcoating here! just an Honest Opinion! After investigating the picture in a large view, I think I have spotted the problem. . . Gulp! Its just not an interesting picture. Artistically it is very well rendered, Technically it is very detailed and complete, but, the overall presentation lacks the ability to generate much interest. Is there a way to improve this picture? technically - No! Artistically - yes, make it more abstract by detailing with contrasting colors. Just my honest opinion, I hope it helped.
0∈ [?]
While trying to create good pictures, I feel as if I am standing on the edge of Insanity. There is a door. I found myself knocking on the door. The door opened.. . . I was knocking from the inside. Oh Rats!
::WENPEDER
07/10/08 12:52 AM GMT
If I wanted "sugarcoating," Jerry, I wouldn't have posted in this section. Thanks for your honest opinion! I'll mull it over carefully and take your suggestion re: "making it more abstract" into consideration. Problem is, I've found that making 3D images such as this more "abstract" tends to prompt feedback that it isn't "realistic" enough..... Thanks again for your effort to help! Wen
0∈ [?]
+trisbert
07/27/08 11:03 AM GMT
Wendy, when viewed as an artistic creation this image has much to be commended. However it isn’t a great wallpaper because people like bright vivid pretty (and or cute) pictures for their wallpaper.

I suggest that you take comfort from the wonderful comments it has received and ignore the c-index.
0∈ [?]
There are three colours, Ten digits and seven notes, its what we do with them that’s important. Ruth Ross
::marcaribe
07/29/08 8:49 PM GMT

How do you make this into a LINK?
http://www.caedes.net/Zephir.cgi?lib=Caedes::Infopage&image=WENPEDER-1205901201.jpg
0∈ [?]
Eat A Peach
+trisbert
07/29/08 10:25 PM GMT
<*a href="put the url here"*>put your title here<*/a*> then remove the four * things

Like this
0∈ [?]
There are three colours, Ten digits and seven notes, its what we do with them that’s important. Ruth Ross
&purmusic
07/30/08 2:09 AM GMT
Need a slight correction Robert in your actual link above.

Not sure what is happening ... what I get is a white page?
0∈ [?]
"One of the virtues of being very young is that you don't let the facts get in the way of your imagination." - Sam Levenson
+trisbert
07/30/08 3:05 AM GMT
Oh I forgot to mention that it’s always a good idea to check that the link works :-)

Thank you Les, it’s fixed.
0∈ [?]
There are three colours, Ten digits and seven notes, its what we do with them that’s important. Ruth Ross
&purmusic
07/30/08 3:49 AM GMT
We, Robert and me that is ... /\ planned the whole thing to bring home the message.

:o)
0∈ [?]
"One of the virtues of being very young is that you don't let the facts get in the way of your imagination." - Sam Levenson

Leave a comment (registration required):

Subject: