Caedes

  Magee Marsh 5  

Click here to view at full resolution.
Uploaded: 10/30/08 1:30 PM GMT
Magee Marsh 5
Views: 647
Dlds: 195
Status: active

I added a little HDR to this picture. I'm not sold on the results of this, but I thought I would post it, and get some honest opinions. Thanks for the comments.

Comments

Post a Comment  -  Subscribe to this discussion
::Roseman_Stan
10/30/08 1:52 PM GMT
Another beauty of a shot Jim! Well done.

Stan
0∈ [?]
“Won't you come into the garden? I would like my roses to see you” - Richard Brinsley Sheridan
.Genver
10/30/08 1:58 PM GMT
The photo is beautiful,very nice colors and sky,the clarity is very good too.
0∈ [?]
.corngrowth
10/30/08 2:42 PM GMT
Don't understand your doubts Jimbob as this is an excellent post my friend!!!
Regards, Cornelius.
0∈ [?]
Better a good amateur than a bad professional. This amateur was here! Don't however say that I'm a good one (lol). Click HERE to see my work!
.icedancer
10/30/08 3:04 PM GMT
WOW Jim this is a gorgeous setting and colours. I can see the bird condo in the distance, but I'll take that beautiful home.
0∈ [?]
::casechaser
10/30/08 4:12 PM GMT
If my retirement money keeps disappearing, I would like to have the bird condo! lol. Jim, great composition and presentation.
0∈ [?]
::Joanie
10/30/08 4:35 PM GMT
I like it and I sorta don't like it. Maybe I'm just not used to you using HDR on your photos. The scene and colors are brilliant! I'm still looking and I'll let you know what I decide..lol..its on my DT!
Joanie
0∈ [?]
Love and live.
.muki7
10/30/08 4:37 PM GMT
A beautiful scene Jimbob. I like the colours and the sky in this image. Your birds sure live in a nice house.

Ed
0∈ [?]
After 50 years of photography I shoot for memories not perfection
.Jims
10/30/08 4:41 PM GMT
I don't know why your not sold on it. It's a great shot and the post work is stellar, Keep up the good work jim. I love it!
0∈ [?]
.Olaus
10/30/08 4:46 PM GMT
I like your job with HDR Jim. Good work.
Christer
0∈ [?]
::Joanie
10/30/08 4:53 PM GMT
Ok...I looked for awhile and I really love it! It looks like a painting of a fancy sort. You can buy me that house if you like!..lol..Excellent work Jim!
Joanie
0∈ [?]
Love and live.
.SatCom
10/30/08 6:06 PM GMT
Don't knock something new untill you try it....Great job on the HDR Jimbob. It's not too overdone and the colors are subtle. Beautiful work and I think you should be proud of this one.

Paul
0∈ [?]
Sometimes I do get to places just when God's ready to have somebody click the shutter. - Ansel Adams....... My Gallery
::cynlee
10/30/08 6:18 PM GMT
I know what HDR is, but I didn't know you could do a 'little'. lol Looks really fine to me Jimbob, and it is definitely the lighting that HDR offers that makes this really stand out. Wonderful job with good definition and fine colors.
0∈ [?]
"Take it upon yourselves to be more forthright in your comments"* *Les (&purmusic)
.mia04
10/30/08 6:26 PM GMT
Perhaps the clouds and the sky are a bit too reddish (if you absolutely want to find something to critizise), but generally I like it very much!
0∈ [?]
For every complex problem, there is a solution that is simple, plausible, and wrong. - H. L. Mencken
.timvdb
10/30/08 8:20 PM GMT
Hi Jim,
I quite enjoy the fantasy like scape,
Some have mentioned the clouds to be a bit reddish, mine are usually to blue, I then desaturate on them and I like the results a lot, seems to bring up a lot of dynamism,
Perhaps you could try that,
Beautifully done,

Thanks for sharing
Kind regards
Tim
0∈ [?]
"I hope you have beautiful colors where you are in the world" Photo.net newsletter (~8
::tigger3
10/30/08 9:32 PM GMT
I think it is a good one Jim. The colors really look good to me.
=^..^= sandi ♪

0∈ [?]
Nature in all her glory is my uplift on life and so is my love of photography. ♪ ♫ ♪sandi ♪ ♫ ♪
::0930_23
10/30/08 11:05 PM GMT
Very good JimboB and you should like this very much. Just look at the comments. It is definetly a keeper.

Tick
0∈ [?]
I'll meet you at the edge of the sunlight, just behind the shadows. Anyone who does not like clouds, does not like to dream. The Ghost
.Ramad
10/30/08 11:28 PM GMT
Whatever you did to this image Jimbob, the result is fascinating! Honest opinion - Very good clarity, and an impressive 3D effect!
0∈ [?]
If practice makes perfect and nobody is perfect, then why practice?
::100k_xle
10/31/08 12:22 AM GMT
Excellent Jim !

E J
0∈ [?]
Love Your Work ! That's Why I Stopped By. Thanks For Sharing !
.Lynthirteen
10/31/08 2:57 AM GMT
I agree with everyone, you have done a wonderful job with this one. Another wonderful sky as well. How do you do it. LOL. Lyn.
0∈ [?]
::SEFA
10/31/08 8:48 AM GMT
It almost looks like Ortons. I like it, it´s beautiful.
0∈ [?]
SEFA
.Inkeri
10/31/08 6:12 PM GMT
So Beautiful scene..Lovely capture with Fine colors.
0∈ [?]
::phasmid
10/31/08 11:39 PM GMT
I think I would have upped the color a bit, but I like the HDR effect, as you can tell by looking at my gallery. It give it a very dynamic touch.

:)PJ
0∈ [?]
We don’t make art to show someone what something looks like. All this requires is eyes (or a lens). Art is supposed to have meaning, emotion, power, or magic. Alan & Mario "FourThirds"
&purmusic
11/01/08 5:24 PM GMT
Ok, since you asked for some opinions ...

*mumbles under his breath, 'like anything has ever stopped me before from putting my two feet into my cookie hole'*

... I shall oblige you.

/\ Just kidding a bit. :oP

Now then ...

Think you present to us a good good HDR image, Jim.

My own personal tastes are for 'understated'. And in saying that, I am not inferring that the 3D aspect is loss. Not at all.

Caveats?

Trying to dredge my memory in terms of the toning and curves work that might address some ... some, mind you ... loss of details in the reds and yellows. Minor, at best.

Perhaps, some additional post processing ... as in some Selective Colour adjustment might bring, or introduce better neutrals and/or blacks? Just some thoughts.


Good composition, very pleasant to view.

And again, personal tastes perhaps and most certainly in my humble opinion ... kind of like the warmth of your image here. Not sure what time you actually shot this, however to my eyes looks like late afternoon light. Nice.

Only when viewing your image at the larger resolutions does some digital noise become readily apparent. Most definitely something that comes into play with HDR imaging. And it is not bad, to be clear here.

Summarizing, nice work. A subtle touch that resulted in a good good one.

Annnnnd ... but of course, thank you for sharing this one with us. :o)
0∈ [?]
"Be the change you wish to see in the world." -Gandhi
::moongirl
11/01/08 11:49 PM GMT
Beautiful post Jim!
0∈ [?]
carissa =D
.gabriela2006
11/02/08 11:02 PM GMT
a wonderful capture and effect....interesting architecture on the house:)
0∈ [?]
::nigelmoore
11/03/08 4:30 AM GMT
I think the HDR is a success JimBob. I like the 3d rendering of the house, it adds to the scene. Especially with the line of the driveway leading up to it. The HDR hasn't affected the way the foliage looks too much either, it's still nice and soft. My one comment would be about the yellow colour cast, which could be easily sorted out with a white balance or curves adjustment. But having said that, it does add a nice golden glow so I wouldn't get rid of it altogether. All in all very successful I think.
0∈ [?]
"A camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera." Dorothea Lange
.annie100
11/03/08 6:47 PM GMT
Absolutly PERFECT autumn shot!!FAVED!!!!
0∈ [?]
.Gabbels
11/05/08 9:41 AM GMT
Fantastic image of this wonderful scenery! I love how the HDR worked out!!
0∈ [?]
When you're through with life and all hope is lost. Hold out your hand 'cos friends will be friends - right till the end.

Leave a comment (registration required):

Subject: