The noise can work for something like this. I also like the choice of sepia. However I am not sure about the cropping/composition. Maybe it's just because I am used to either portrait or landscape format... I like it though.
A really interesting image. I'm still trying to decide whether the noise is from an underexposed image that was corrected or added for effect, and if it helps or detracts from the overall image. Maybe as a black and white it would give the feel of a stippled drawing and I would like it but I think I'd increase the exposure in the sky so it didn't look muddy. I do like the composition and the angle very much but I would have like three full blooms or just the two without the one cropped off in the corner. The sepia tone almost seems like the tulips are trying to find the sun through a smoggy L.A. day. I think it might be fun for you to play with some different color options and see what happens. anne =D
Critiquing art of any kind is utterly subjective. When I vote on your images, I look at several things. First, my initial gut reaction. Then, is it straight (if it should be); is the color correct or if intentionally saturated or desaturated, was it done properly and does it enhance the image; composition - if you intended a bulls-eye, unless it's an outstanding image that is really served by centering the subject, it'll get dinged; is the horizon dead center - again, unless there's an obvious reason that makes it a better photo, no points; is the subject interesting and uncluttered; is the image sharp; is the depth of field right for this composition, is there a catchlight in the creature's eye; would I hang this on my wall; is it an image I'd be proud to display; is it artistic or just a snapshot; does it move me; is there a message conveyed; is it documentary in nature and if so, does it tell the story in such a way it makes me want more. When I critique a photo in your gallery, I'm only suggesting what my subjective nature prefers. No need to defend your position if you like your image the way it is. If you give me constructive criticism on my pieces, I guarantee you I will take them to heart. I love to improve! Bring it on Caedians! Love, anne =D
Thanks for the comments but if you guys are asking me about that noise, i added it myself. i did couple experiments but i liked with noise better. i will try my best next time to get better a shot and in editing.
I really like the sepia tone.