Certainly an interesting portrait and you've captured the subject in an interesting (and appropriate) setting. I feel that the lighting isn't quite as good as I'd like to see, especially around the face where the shadow from the roof overhang is interfering with some of the detail. Love the colors in the clothes and "accessory".

Yes...the men are running away from home because they don't want to be couped up in caves with their wives. Nice pic, you can see she appears somewhat forlorn that her man is running away.

Hi Jen..this people image tells a story as does your narrative that you included. I like how she is looking away and holding a blanket? maybe out the window. The viewer is able to get a glimpse inside the window of the poverty that these Indians live with every day. There is a discrepancy in the lighting due to the overhand of the roof that tends to distract a bit from her face, but overall, the composition is good, the quality is high and the clarity is..well, clear! Thanks for telling me the story of the Tarahumara Indians. Very fascinating. ;=)

Ok, why not ... I was in on that thread discussion ... I most certainly do not think this is a snapshot by any stretch.

It is a contemplative portrait ... both of the subject, and for this viewer.

Slight shortcomings aside ... I think this is a compelling image. Well composed ... and that face ... that face is beautiful.

Add in your narrative ... thanks for taking the proverbial leap. I like this.

Desktop material? I don't think that is a pertinent question.

wonderful portrait Jen! Did you use a zoom to take this photograph or was she aware that you were there? She looks oblious and that is what makes it a great photo! Patti

I agree with Patti here. She does not seem to be aware of you, which makes it a more real portrait for me. Her face is 'lived in', interesting and relaxed with good detail, although she is in shade. The setting only adds to our knowledge of her circumstances. A great portrait taken in difficult circumstances.. Well done.

Hi Jen. Its a good shot.There is so much life in this.

Always good to see another culture and their people's surrounding-if only a glimpse.as for "poverty". I suspect she and her people are happier than many of us in the industrialized world....I like the portrait very much and if some are calling this a "snapshot", then.well.too bad...it is anything but.....lighting is natural and I would not brighten her face as this would distort her natural state..

This ain't no "snapshot". This is an artistic capture worthy of anyone's time taken to view and comment on it. I had no idea that these people existed much less still lived in the primiative conditions that they do. Thks for enlightening me, Jen. Got any more?
Pat

What a Fantastic portrait,Jen..and a Wonderful capture..Love it..

Great shot! I agree with Pat. This is a classic.

Did you take this with a telephoto, Jen? Did you have to ask her permission to take her picture or was she unaware that you were? I find it a sensitive matter when trying to include people in my shots. You said they were reclusive, so I was wondering about it.
She has a very remarkable face. I am in awe of such people. They are merely protecting their ways and their traditions. What has modernity ever fostered for some ancient peoples but grief? I don't blame them their reclusivity. I regret that I don't have more people shots from my travels. I wonder how they make a living, the Tarahumaras. I see she is wearing a nightgown with a Christmas theme! That's interesting in itself. I love the structure and textures of the building and the roof. This is a wonderful capture, Jen.

Have you thought about applying for a job at the National Geographic, Jen? This is outstanding! You've really capture a PERSON here, along with a STORY. Wonderful shot! Wen

I like it for all the good reasons stated previously. No negative ideas on lighting or anything else. You took a great photo, thanks.

Hey that is a nice photo. Did you notice the Christmas clothing she is wearing. Thanks for sharing it.

I agree, this is an artistic portrait, full of emotion and revealing a lot of things about her life's conditions. Excellent image. :)

What a meaningful expression she has and you've captured it perfectly Jen. Excellent post.

Quite a shot, Jen. Not one that can be taken in with a mere glance. Very good detail brought out and an excellent choice of subject.

Jen ,
Your Image can create lot of stories ;-)
Nice shot.

The face tells the story of a hard life. You caught a great photo.

A fine and interesting portrait.Her face and the details in the surroundings tells us something about the culture there.Nice photo,Jen.

I can not praise this picture enough, and I don't need to as I think everything has been said. I would just like to add my accolade to the list :)

I love these images and I never really see many of them. Thank you for sharing how others live.

This is a very unique capture, and like many others...I find it especially courageous when somebody snaps a "people"shot like this. It is a difficault and awkward thing when you ask others for a shot { and they aren't friends/family. Also...it takes a special flair to do a "people" shot that comes off as artistic, rather than snap-shot.
You did a great job!

This is a superb portrait. I fully agree with all the good things that have already been said. Most people do not post portraits on Caedes because of the "desktop" issue, but I am extremely grateful you have shared this wonderful photo with us.

Agree! The best of your portraits IMO.
I moved it in the people gallery. Well desserved.
Your composition is excellent!