Excellent rework. In spite of of some slightly sharp edges, the composition and BG palette work very well.

Lori, the center composition adds to the drama of your image. This is beautifully done, lighting just right and very pleasing to see! - Patty

I like the shot of the rose no matter what you do with the background, but this view really spotlights that beautiful rose with no other distraction what so ever. I want to take a bite of this rose, it looks so delicious. LOL

You did a great rework here Lori. Everything is still right on from the previous photo but the focus now is definitely right on the rose and doesn't get distracted by the background. Beauty on full screen. Thanks for sharing it. Anita

This is great, Lori. Very striking. Can't imagine why you'd be unsure about this.
Certainly, it's been somewhat removed from it's environment, but the end result is exceptional, and the flower hasn't been altered, only enhanced.
Well done.

Well, now I really can't decide between this and the earlier version, and I understand what your reservations were. But I THINK I like this plain background better...my personal preference would've made it a tone or two lighter...

Anastasia, still trying to decide.

love it like this! :) gorgeous rose to begin with...

I love this rework. The solitude is more defined and brings a whole different mood to the image.

Oh this is magnificient!!!!!!! How much more beautiful can anything be! It gives me soft shivers all thru my body, no kidding. I used to know how to do the "blackout" like this, but I dont know how anymore. Any hints? I have PSP and also Photoshop. I dont even know how to use the clone thingie...can ya help me? I love love love this kind of shot..I mean, it is absolutely the epitome of elegance my friend! I have always loved yellow roses MOST of all, but I think this colour of yours has the yellow beat! Its absolutely gorgeous. Congrats...and I have it in my Favs, and will be putting it on my desktop soon!..many soft hugs to ya...verena

Well, verenabloo just said it all better than I could :) I found this beauty in the voting booth. Utter Perfection :)

Well, Pat just stole my 2 word comment....utter perfection. I guess if anything's worth saying, it's worth saying twice. LOL

What a great picture. Wish I could do that...I never see flowers like that. Super job.

Oh, this is one gorgeous rose. Super in all ways - clarity, color and detail. Those petals appear so soft. The drops of dew are very appealing. The pale pink petals against the inner pale peach shade is stunning. The maroon background serves this glorious rose well. Lori, your work is magnificent - like the others said * utter perfection* :*>

Beautiful! I truly does look like it is blushing.
-İME

Very nice!!!
Absolutely a beautiful rework:)

The rework works so well! Good one.. Mich