Standing on my head allows this image to make more 'sense' to me but takes away the novelty of viewing a reflection in the sky and the mystery that invokes.
Flipping the image gives a better balance (in my eyes at least)and I like seeing the reflected trees without them being visible above.
This way up I would go along with 5/10 with an extra 1 for novelty value but t'other way up I would give it 6.
So it's six of one and half a dozen of the other, on the face of it, but I would likely mark it higher for causing me to pause and reflect.

I think you've short-changing yourself, Chris...while it may lack impact it has alot of mystique, ambience, and does indeed make the viewer pause to consider what they are viewing...and for those who enjoy a little of the abstract or impressionism, it also has merit...the black and white an added bonus as well...I'm with Lyn, 6/10.

It might be interesting to crop away the bottom portion of the image so the viewer has to think even harder about what he is seeing.

Hi Chris. The loss of impact rectifies quite a bit when viewed full screen because of the "textured" look from the former water - now sky. I think it would be even more interesting if you replaced the scene being reflected with a morph of the actual reflected image (if that makes sense). I do love the concept here and do like this one a lot.