On at least two other sites, on each member's profile, in addition to their gallery, the critiques they offer are also listed. Could someting like that be done here? Perhaps seeing the critiques left by someone in a group, would put their comments into a better context.

Thoughts?

you mean .. we'd have a place to come if we ran out of syrup for our pancakes?

uh... no.

Well really all you have to do is go to the members gallery and look at the thank yous they have recieved. Then search for the image;-)

true, but then you're looking at alot more legwork, as opposed to a compiled list.

Actually just finger work ha

they say: "Gold is where you find it ... and, if by Critique, you mean Critique ... then, following this button labeled Critique will not lead you to, or find any Critique at the resulting destinations

for the most part .. generally speaking .. of course

but!!!!! .. long after you've already melted your brain reading "Oh WOW, Martha, that's a nice shot ... a photographer that consistently posts quality imagery will occasionally say .. "the colors are a little flat, you should adjust them"

how, then, do you categorize that person's commentary? .. was your time well spent? ..

I think it was Bob Dylan, who said .. "How Many Words Must A Man Write Down, Before You Call Him A Man?"

the 'other' sites that you hint at are likely full of people who are there to post there opinions as much as they are there to post their images ... if you "PM" somebody at the dslreports.com/forum/ .. you are likely to be greeted by an In-Box preamble that says "If you are writing me to complain about a critique I left on your image, don't bother .. I couldn't care less"