I tried this once, with disappointing results. From memory I think I had sharply contrasting areas of sunlight and shade which were exaggerated by the prolonged exposure and that made the result unappealing.
If your shooting in the sun you will almost certainly need a neutral density filter to cut down the amount of light. Other than that...
I see you have done HDR so I will suggest using that to your advantage. Set it up so that the middle exposure will be no more than 1/8 second and go 2 stops over and under from there. Start with a longer exposure if you want the water to become completely milky smooth. This is one I did using this method and manually blending the shots in Photoshop.(Manually masked in layers. Not merge to HDR.) Duvall Branch It is much much easier on an overcast day. just setup the shot for a 1/8 second or longer exposure. Should look something like this - The falls
People aren't going to remember the things you do. They're going to remember how you made people feel. Be kind, gracious, and appreciative. Dan Winters - Photographer.