I don't think this is too bad; it's more subtle (ie not as shiny) as the usual but that's not necessarily a bad thing. DId you follow nmsmith's tutorial? If not you should check it out.
I actually did follow nmsmith's tutorial but this is the VERY first time I've ever used photoshop so I'm actually proud that I could pull off this good of an image heh. (it coulda ended up looking like the wal-mart smiley EW)