Ooo I was just in Arizona in November on a class trip and I'm pretty sure we passed Cathedral Rock. I know we went to Bell Rock though. Nice angle and everything on this picture though. I don't think it's redundant at all.
~Meg
Good placement of the rock (framing). Look at all that water running in the desert. That's a capture in and of itself. I think I might have hot the "saturation: button once or twice on this photo. A great and unique capture none the less.
Pat
Your angle, your photo....I think it is great!