Log In or Register
Ended 03/14/12 3:15 AM GMT
Winner: LynEve
(See the full results)
1st place LakeMichigan: Very creative and well done . Good luck in the contest.
wheedance: What a wonderful idea and presentation! Congrats!
Roseman_Stan: Congrats on your contest win Lyn!!! Happy for you!!
purmusic: Really nice, Lyn.
Caveats?
Undecided, really.. as to whether the crop is a tad tight.
And it has not gone unnoticed by me, that you were working with the physical constraints/size of the wood top. Just can't quite shake the thought of a bit more breathing room to the right of the rose might be an improvement.
That said..
Good good control and handle on the technical considerations. Lighting is nice, too.
p.s. Then, it hits me.. the size of the sides of your border/framing.
See if the following joke reference makes sense..
As an added punishment for prisoners.. jail house authorities are considering placing the bars on the prison inmate uniforms.. horizontal.
('Cause.. then the prisoners would go around thinking that they are 'fat'. :oP)
To my eyes, and mind.. with the border width/size at the sides as presented.. kind of, sort of ... fights with the vertical lines of the bottle and the hanging watches.
Downloaded and cropped on the above thought(s) ... looks better?
LynEve received a 2 month membership in the Caedes Cadre.
2nd place
purmusic: Add me to the list that enjoy your image here.
And..
Been trying to figure out whether or not you did some stuff in post processing, or.. shot this one through something?
(There are elements in/of the bokeh that add to this mystery of sorts, to my eyes and mind.)
I don't think, and I could be wrong.. that simply dialing in the DOF is the visual result of what we are seeing within frame.
Like Bethany above, a part of me does wish to see more of.. as in, a wider/deeper DOF.
On the note of sharpening, and in my humble opinion ... clarity and focus, as is ... and presented, with respect to the areas in focus ... are fine.
Exposure is good good. Composition as well.
Very nice shot and one that would keep me looking at it for some.. ahem ... time. There's lots to like and take in, despite it's simplicity.
coram9 received a 1 month membership in the Caedes Cadre.
3rd place
purmusic: Really nice work, Hannah.
If I may.. composition.
In my humble opinion, think you could make some 'minor' (on the notes of your concept and overall presentation) changes.
Moon ... smaller.
Allowing for the Xaos fractal to provide stronger leading lines within frame, prodding your viewer's eyes to look into your piece.. deeper. As they are a nice touch.
Add some more depth, in short.
And in turn, knock down the moon's prominence (visual weight), too.
Will summarize my thoughts here.. in a popular phrasing..
'+favs for me.'
Best of luck in the contest with this very strong creative contender. :o)
5th place zunazet: Congrats on placing in the contest. A very fine tribute to all.
casechaser: Congrats on your win, Jo.
0930_23: Congratulations for placing in the contest Baby Cakes. It was a great honor for you and your grandfather.
TicK