Although the painting effect doesn't spoil this image, it does take away alot of the magick that can be enjoyed in the photograph. I love this image. Removing the female that can be seen in the original was good advice well taken. But my humble and honest opinion is that I would much prefer to see the photo. I feel that the photo has much more potential to be 'iconic' portrayal of winter.

great picture,the canvas on the pond should be smooth not showing the canvas on the picture.I love the scene.great.

I think I like your first somewhat better too. Although they both are beautiful I think the grain of the canvas look takes a little bit away from it. Nicely captured!!

Hey Larry, I checked out both versions of this. I like them both, and agree that it was a good idea to lose the female cardinal. I really love the simplicity of this image, and with the addition of the one red cardinal, really makes it special. As for the painted look, I think it's very nice and I have taken it for my DT, but would love to know if you ever choose to post this without the painting effect, as I think I would like it even more. Thanks for sharing....and great work!
Lori

p.s...Going to check out the rest of your gallery :)