Log In or Register
Submitted by caedes 09/07/05 4:55 PM GMT
I'm glad that we have had so much discussion and new ideas on ways that the voting system and c-index *shudder* can be improved. As you may have heard, I have been working on a new system which I believe will fix most of the problems with the current one. The core idea behind this new system is that members will be asked to vote on specific (randomly chosen) images when they visit the site. The vote request will show up in your "Jobs" control panel when you are logged in. You will not know who the image is by and you will have to view the full size version before voting. Afterwards you have the option of visiting the image and making a comment. The advantages of this system are as follows:
I also feel that the random c-index should be separated from the selective c-index. Or maybe we should be able to choose for ourselves which we'd prefer to see.
On the Shutterpoint site the system allows random voters to base their vote on several factors (Exposure / Dramatic Effect / Tonal Range / Tells A Story / Depth Of Field / Graininess / Focus). Each factor can be voted between 1 and 5 (Poor / Below Average / Fair / Good / Excellent), then the various factors are averaged to produce a rating. Each voter's distribution of votes is then analyzed to produce a weight that is applied to the average, and the result is the vote. If the voter uses the detailed voting system it counts more towards his vote / upload ratio.
This comment by DixieNormus has been moved to the Hall of Shame.
Overflow mode, hiding 265 messages. [View]